Journal Article
13 Sep 2018
150 views

Barbies, Goddesses, and Entrepreneurs: Discourses of Gendered Digital Embodiment in Women’s Health Apps

Women's Studies in Communication Marissa J. Doshi
Women's Studies in Communication
Marissa J. Doshi
Region of the Americas
1 download
Access the article
What you'll learn
Critically evaluating women's health apps from a feminist perspective
  • This study presents an intersectional qualitative analysis of women’s health apps, exploring how they perpetuate American cultural norms and idealised constructions of women’s health
  • The results show that the healthy female body promoted by these apps embodies three archetypes: (1) Barbie; (2) Earth goddess; and (3) entrepreneur
  • The authors provide feminist guidance to app designers and encourage women to critically evaluate these apps as users
Key Takeaways
1
Diversifying types of bodies in women's health apps
Diversifying types of bodies in women's health apps

App designers should increase the diversity of bodies featured in the icons of apps and use descriptors that challenge these harmful normative expectations of health.

2
Many health apps have the effect of stigmatising certain groups of women
Many health apps have the effect of stigmatising certain groups of women

This includes those who are unable or choose not to reproduce, those experiencing negative emotions, women exploring sexual health apart from reproduction, women who are not heterosexual, and transwomen – by framing motherhood and female fertility as necessary, joyful, and disconnected from sexual pleasure. This should be avoided.

3
Health app designers should focus on inclusivit
Health app designers should focus on inclusivit

Health app designers should focus on inclusivity and avoid the emphasis on the need for constant monitoring and improvement of one’s body and self-promotion, which transfers the burden of appropriate care from health providers to the patient, while app vendors make a profit. This is particularly harmful to low-income women, especially women of colour, who are often systematically denied health care and blamed for their poor health.

Two women on the beach in Coney Island

Enacting entrepreneurship in the context of health requires time (apps demand routine and disciplined engagement) and money (advanced features often require payment), both of which are outside the realm of possibility for women in poverty who might manage multiple jobs, lack surplus income, and have precarious access to basic services and needs.

Affiliations
  1. Marissa J. Doshi – Department of Communication, Hope College, Holland, MI, USA
Related research, resources and events
Article
05 Dec 2023
3k views
What works? Integrating gender into government health programmes in Africa, South Asia, and Southeast Asia
Article
19 Nov 2023
22 views
2023 Gender and Health Hub Virtual Forum Evidence. Voice. Action: Catalysing Change for Gender and Health Equality
Article
08 Nov 2023
52 views
Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights and Bodily Autonomy in a Digital World
Article
14 Mar 2023
53 views
Uncovering the diamond in the rough: Selecting promising cases of gender integration in government health programs across Africa, South Asia and Southeast Asia
Article
14 Mar 2023
26 views
A Compendium of the History of Gender Mainstreaming in Five United Nations Agencies
Article
06 Mar 2023
1 view
The Personal is Political: Re-imagining Data Governance in the context of Digital Health
Article
06 Dec 2022
85 views
“The Power of Feminist Leadership” Think Piece and Podcast Series
Article
05 Dec 2022
1 view
Participatory Planning and Paying for Local Action Plans to Address Gender-Based Violence: Lessons from Indonesia, Peru and the Republic of Moldova
Article
05 Dec 2022
1 view
Call for Papers: Digital Technology and Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights
Article
27 Nov 2022
377 views
What Works in Gender and Health in the United Nations – Case Study Series
Article
22 Nov 2022
6 views
Transformative Feminist Leadership In Global Health: From Rhetoric to Action
Article
05 Oct 2022
440 views
Gender Equity in Immunisation and Vaccine Development, Deployment, Access, and Uptake: Lessons From COVID-19 for Future Policy Pathways
Article
09 Sep 2022
209 views
Caring for women subjected to violence: A WHO curriculum for training health-care providers 44
Article
08 Sep 2022
189 views
‘Ending GBV and Achieving the SDGs’: taking stock of lessons learned from local responses to GBV
Article
18 Aug 2022
768 views
Mapping of potential case studies on gender integration in government health programs across Africa, South Asia and South East Asia
Article
03 Aug 2022
2k views
“The Power of The Collective” Think Piece and Podcast Series
Article
18 Jul 2022
43 views
Gender and Health Hub Email Newsletter Archive
Article
04 Jul 2022
93 views
Gender and Health Hub Annual Survey Results 2022
Article
04 Jul 2022
133 views
Limited gender data deepens inequalities
Article
22 Jun 2022
225 views
Gender activism, politics, and intersectionality in the era of COVID-19
Article
23 May 2022
196 views
Gender violence in health institutions as a global health issue
Article
16 May 2022
103 views
Radically sensible: Feminist philanthropy in global health | With Jessica Horn
Article
15 Apr 2022
366 views
Vaccines to vaccinations: Gender in Promoting Immunisation
Article
03 Mar 2022
1k views
Charting Transferability: Advancing gender equality in the response to climate change
Article
17 Dec 2021
795 views
Address gender barriers in delivery and demand to catalyse COVID-19 vaccine equity: The Asia Pacific context
Article
08 Dec 2021
789 views
The Digital Gender Gap in HealthCare: Progress, Challenges, and Policy Implications
Article
06 Dec 2021
2k views
What Works in Gender and Health in the United Nations: Lessons Learned from Cases of Successful Gender Mainstreaming across Five UN Agencies
Article
11 Nov 2021
3k views
UNU Gender and Health Hub: Annual Forum
Article
24 Oct 2021
3k views
“The Power of Feminist Civil Society” Think Piece and Podcast Series
Article
22 Oct 2021
702 views
Designing process evaluations of digital health programs with a gender lens (Case studies from India)
Article
15 Oct 2021
128 views
Women, Health and Gender equality: Commit, accelerate, scale up!
Article
12 Oct 2021
85 views
Gender & COVID-19 Research Agenda Setting in Asia Pacific: Vaccinations
Article
12 Oct 2021
291 views
Reflections on emerging COVID-19 research priorities for gender and governance of health systems: Please vote by 15th October!
Article
09 Sep 2021
924 views
Social Media, Networks, and Movements for Women’s Empowerment
Article
01 Sep 2021
2k views
“The Power of Evidence” Think Piece and Podcast Series
Article
01 Sep 2021
472 views
“The Power Of…” Think Piece and Podcast Series
Article
18 Aug 2021
1k views
Gender and Health Research Agenda Setting for COVID-19: Initial Results
Article
16 Aug 2021
787 views
Gender and Phone Surveys: Methodological Considerations
Article
11 Aug 2021
255 views
COVID-19: the turning point for gender equality
Article
04 Aug 2021
320 views
Tackling gender-related barriers in COVID-19 vaccine delivery and uptake in LMICs
Article
08 Jul 2021
835 views
Gender and Digital Health Webinar Series
Article
01 Jul 2021
467 views
Big data and AI for gender equity in health
Article
24 Jun 2021
337 views
Integrating Gender and Sex Informed Evidence into Tobacco Control Policy and Practice: What Works?
Article
15 Jun 2021
426 views
Sex and gender in COVID-19 vaccines: data, policy, and communication
Article
15 Jun 2021
940 views
Generation Equality Forum: Building a feminist health sector in response to Covid-19
Article
08 Jun 2021
184 views
Consultation on Gender and COVID-19: Research in Middle East and North Africa
Article
08 Jun 2021
130 views
Consultation on Gender and COVID-19: Research in West and Central Africa
Article
25 May 2021
370 views
Tackling gender-related barriers to equitable COVID-19 vaccine deployment
Article
25 May 2021
578 views
Digital literacy for women: Definitions, measurement, curriculums, and theories of change
Article
29 Apr 2021
210 views
What causes the digital gender gap?
Article
26 Mar 2021
4k views
Guidance note and checklist for tackling gender-related barriers to equitable COVID-19 vaccine deployment
Article
25 Mar 2021
392 views
Women and digital tools can create healthier and more equal societies
Article
25 Mar 2021
67 views
Health Systems Research Symposium (HSR2020)
Article
25 Mar 2021
253 views
Gender-based violence and technology during Covid-19
Article
24 Mar 2021
79 views
World Health Summit 2021
Article
24 Mar 2021
322 views
The UNU Gender and Health Hub: A nexus to people, knowledge, policy and action for gender equality
Article
24 Mar 2021
58 views
Generation Equality Forum 2021
Article
24 Mar 2021
52 views
The World Health Assembly 2021
Article
23 Mar 2021
518 views
Gender Inequities and Financial Protection for Healthcare Access: An Infographic Series
Article
23 Mar 2021
229 views
Sexual & Reproductive Health Services: An Infographic Series
Article
23 Mar 2021
938 views
The Gender Gap in Digital Health: An Infographic Series
Article
23 Mar 2021
480 views
Gender-Based Violence Response Services: An Infographic Series
Article
15 Mar 2021
88 views
Commission on the Status of Women (CSW65) 2021
Article
04 Mar 2021
207 views
Case studies in Government responses to the COVID-19 pandemic: how has technology been used to address women’s health needs and what are the gaps?
Article
09 Feb 2021
611 views
What, Why and How: Gender & COVID-19 Research Agenda-setting
Article
28 Jan 2021
322 views
What Does the Digital Gender Gap Mean for Healthcare?
Article
24 Jan 2021
225 views
Delivering health interventions to women, children, and adolescents in conflict settings: what have we learned from ten country case studies?
Article
09 Jan 2021
484 views
Women’s Health and Gender Inequalities
Article
15 Dec 2020
73 views
What Works in Gender and Health Webinar Series
Article
10 Dec 2020
281 views
How to create a gender-responsive pandemic plan: Addressing the secondary effects of COVID-19
Article
09 Dec 2020
277 views
Universal Health Coverage, Gender Equality and Social Protection: A Health Systems Approach
Article
27 Oct 2020
141 views
BMJ Collection – Women’s Health and Gender Inequalities: Lessons and Emerging Priorities 25 years after the Beijing Platform for Action
Article
09 Oct 2020
169 views
Prevention Collaborative Factsheets
Article
15 Sep 2020
632 views
Incorporating Intersectional Gender Analysis into Research on Infectious Diseases of Poverty: A Toolkit for Health Researchers
Article
29 Jul 2020
204 views
Gender-transformative programming with men and boys to improve sexual and reproductive health and rights: a systematic review of intervention studies
Article
08 Jul 2020
203 views
Women are most affected by pandemics — lessons from past outbreaks
Article
16 Mar 2020
247 views
Connected Women: The Mobile Gender Gap Report 2020
Article
17 Feb 2020
245 views
Gender and MNCH: A Review of the Evidence
Article
12 Feb 2020
216 views
Gender and Malaria Evidence Review
Article
10 Jan 2020
229 views
Climate change, gender equality and human rights in Asia: regional review and promising practices
Article
09 Jan 2020
249 views
What works to prevent violence against women and girls? A rigorous global evidence review of interventions to prevent violence against women and girls
Article
04 Jan 2020
307 views
Adopting a gender lens in health systems policy: A guide for policy makers
Article
03 Dec 2019
165 views
Evaluating a Tool to Support the Integration of Gender in Programs to Promote Men’s Health
Article
27 Nov 2019
129 views
A forgotten group during humanitarian crises: a systematic review of sexual and reproductive health interventions for young people including adolescents in humanitarian settings
Article
12 Aug 2019
135 views
Gender and HIV Key Populations: Summary of Evidence-Based Interventions
Article
10 Jun 2019
185 views
Promoting gender equality in sexual, reproductive, maternal, newborn, child and adolescent health: Programming Guide
Article
09 Jun 2019
238 views
Caring for women subjected to violence: A WHO curriculum for training health-care providers
Article
05 Jun 2019
140 views
Delivering Healthy Lives and Well-Being for Women and Girls: Noncommunicable Diseases and Universal Health Coverage
Article
30 May 2019
222 views
Disrupting gender norms in health systems: making the case for change
Article
14 Mar 2019
159 views
Taking Stock: Data and Evidence on Gender Equality in Digital Access, Skills, and Leadership
Article
09 Mar 2019
268 views
Gender equity in the health workforce: Analysis of 104 countries
Article
12 Jan 2019
677 views
Malaria Matchbox Tool: An equity assessment tool to improve the effectiveness of malaria programs
Article
17 Dec 2018
124 views
Opportunities for linking research to policy: lessons learned from implementation research in sexual and reproductive health within the ANSER network
Article
16 Dec 2018
223 views
Gender Toolkit: Integrating Gender in Programming for Every Child in South Asia
Article
12 Nov 2018
164 views
UNAIDS Gender Assessment Tool: Towards a gender-transformative HIV response
Article
11 Oct 2018
146 views
Gender dynamics in digital health: overcoming blind spots and biases to seize opportunities and responsibilities for transformative health systems
Article
06 Jul 2018
247 views
Gendered health systems: evidence from low- and middle-income countries
Article
04 Jul 2018
205 views
Gender-Responsive Tobacco Control: Evidence and Options for Policies and Programmes
Article
09 May 2018
125 views
Accelerate progress—sexual and reproductive health and rights for all: report of the Guttmacher–Lancet Commission
Article
16 Jan 2018
146 views
MenEngage Alliance Accountability Training Toolkit
Article
10 Jan 2018
210 views
WHO recommendations on adolescent sexual and reproductive health and rights
Article
09 Jan 2018
148 views
COFEM Feminist Pocketbook
Article
12 Nov 2017
124 views
20 years of gender mainstreaming in health: lessons and reflections for the neglected tropical diseases community
Article
25 Sep 2017
254 views
Changing times? Gender roles and relationships in maternal, newborn and child health in Malawi
Article
09 Sep 2017
138 views
Because Women Matter: Designing interventions in food, nutrition and agriculture that allow women to change their lives
Article
25 Jul 2017
187 views
Minding the gaps: health financing, universal health coverage and gender
Article
10 Jun 2017
107 views
State of the World’s Fathers: Latin America and the Caribbean
Article
05 Apr 2017
124 views
Women on the move: migration, care work and health
Article
22 Nov 2016
162 views
A synthesis of convergent reflections, tensions and silences in linking gender and global environmental change research
Article
14 Jun 2016
44 views
A tool for strengthening gender-sensitive national HIV and Sexual and Reproductive Health monitoring and evaluation systems
Article
12 Jan 2016
108 views
Gender assessment tool for national HIV and TB responses
Article
12 Dec 2015
113 views
Discussion Paper: Gender and Tuberculosis – Making the investment case for programming that addresses the specific vulnerabilities and needs of both males and females who are affected by or at risk of tuberculosis
Article
16 Sep 2015
84 views
Gender Considerations Along the HIV Treatment Cascade: An Evidence Review with Priority Actions
Article
16 Apr 2015
166 views
mHealth and Gender: Making the Connection
Article
09 Apr 2015
161 views
Enhancing Nutrition and Food Security during the First 1,000 Days through Gender-Sensitive Social and Behavior Change: A Technical Resource Guide
Article
09 Apr 2015
116 views
The health-systems response to violence against women
Article
16 Dec 2014
206 views
Tools for Assessing Gender in Health Policies and Programs
Article
22 Oct 2014
73 views
Health systems and gender in post-conflict contexts: building back better?
Article
22 May 2014
137 views
Women’s empowerment and child nutritional status in South Asia: a synthesis of the literature
Article
28 Apr 2014
141 views
Barriers and Delays in Tuberculosis Diagnosis and Treatment Services: Does Gender Matter?
Article
14 Oct 2013
140 views
Women’s Empowerment and Nutrition: An Evidence Review
Article
10 Aug 2013
101 views
Gender-Transformative Interventions to Reduce HIV Risks and Violence with Heterosexually-Active Men: A Review of the Global Evidence
Article
12 Jul 2013
51 views
Synthesising Gender Based HIV Interventions in Sub-Sahara Africa: A Systematic Review of the Evidence
Article
10 Jul 2013
150 views
Addressing Gender and Women’s Empowerment in mHealth for MNCH
Article
03 Jan 2011
208 views
Evidence for gender responsive actions to promote mental health: Young people’s health as a whole-of-society response
Article
16 Jun 2009
363 views
Intersectionality: Moving Women’s Health Research and Policy Forward
Article
04 Jan 2007
141 views
Integrating Poverty and Gender into Health Programmes: Sourcebook for Health Professionals – Module on Noncommunicable Diseases